Evergreen Lodge Lakefront

Great vacation rentals!

Had a Great stay in the Birch Cabin. Property was in great shape and the kayaks on the lake were really fun.

We had a fantastic week at the Cedars cabin! Close proximity to everything we needed including the All star village baseball facility (about 12 mins), 35 mins from the Baseball Hall of Fame, and about 15 mins to other nearby restaurants/shopping. The cabin was well-appointed and a welcomed escape from the hustle bustle of the baseball tournament. Our family enjoyed the lake, kayaks, campfires and fishing every evening. Owner was responsive and accommodating. If we ever return to the area, we would definitely stay here again!

We had an amazing family getaway here! The cabin was spotless, cozy, and surrounded by beautiful forest, making it the perfect place to relax and disconnect. We enjoyed grilling on the porch, sitting around the campfire at night, and waking up to the peaceful sounds of nature. The property was private, well maintained, and had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. Our kids loved exploring the woods, and we can't wait to come back. Highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a peaceful forest retreat! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

We just stayed here for Week 4 of the 2026 Cooperstown All Star Village experience, and it was absolutely amazing! This is the perfect location — so close to the fields and incredibly convenient. The house had plenty of space for our family, and we loved all the extras: the beautiful lake, relaxing hot tub, and cozy fire pit. We had several families from our team stay at this location, with everyone having their own house, which made it even more special. Mike, the owner, was fantastic — always available, helpful, and quick to answer any questions. This was hands down one of the best decisions we made for our Cooperstown trip. We highly recommend staying here! 💯⚾️

Beautiful property, amazing customer service, gorgeous cabin, and amenities. We would stay there again.

Such a great weekend getaway. We played board games, went fishing and just had a nice time as a family away from the stress of real life. We stayed at the secluded log cabin. It was close enough where we could go into town for groceries but secluded enough that we felt isolated. Hammock was also a major hit with the kids. Cabin itself was clean and comfortable. A/c & heater worked very well. Even the window tracks were clean making windows easy to open to let a breeze in. Plenty of kitchen items including skewers for s'mores that we forgot to pack. I think my only complaint is having 4 dining chairs when max occupancy is 5. Such a minor detail and it did not ruined out experience, especially as we brought our camping chairs.

Very beautiful quiet cabin in the woods. We truly enjoyed our stay. Michael was responsive and very helpful. I look forward to staying here again next season for Cooperstown All Star Village tournament!