Questions? Call Us Anytime. (201) 247-1002

Send Us an Email catskillscabinrentals@gmail.com

Catskill Cabin Rentals
Main Menu
A glass of amber whiskey etched with the Cooperstown Distillery logo

Cooperstown Distillery Guide 2026: Tastings, Cocktails, and Local Spirits

Snow on the porch rail, a fire in the woodstove, and nowhere you need to be. Winter in a Catskills cabin is made for slow days. When you’re ready to get out for an afternoon, head into Cooperstown, where the county’s only distillery pours bourbon, rye, gin, and vodka made almost entirely from New York State grain. Cooperstown Distillery gives you a warm tasting counter, a cocktail lounge on Main Street, and a bottle to bring back for the fire.

This guide covers the distillery’s history, what to order, how its two Cooperstown locations differ, and what to expect if you visit in late 2026 or early 2027.

How Baseball’s Hometown Got Its First Distillery

Cooperstown Distillery opened in 2013 on Railroad Avenue, less than a mile from the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Founder and distiller Gene Marra built the brand around the village’s two best-known stories: baseball and the novels of James Fenimore Cooper. In a 2017 interview with Beverage Dynamics, he said the Cooperstown theme was the most important part of the business plan from the start. It remains the first and only distillery in Otsego County.

Production centers on a custom copper still built by the Carl family of Stuttgart, Germany, which serves as the focal point of the Railroad Avenue building. Most of the grain that goes into it is grown in New York State.

The distillery’s story took a turn in 2020. COVID delayed a planned expansion by a year, and the staff spent part of that time producing hand sanitizer. When the expanded building opened, Marra said he believed the distillery had helped revive a stretch of Railroad Avenue that had looked dead for years. The project added a rackhouse for aging whiskey and bourbon barrels, doubled the staff from five to twelve, and gave the distillery room to grow its supply of aging whiskey from 550 barrels toward a goal of 1,500.

What to Order

The Whiskey Lineup

Whiskey is the focus at Cooperstown Distillery. The Cooperstown Select portfolio includes a straight bourbon, a rye, an American whiskey, and a single malt. The Select Straight Bourbon uses a four-grain mash bill of corn, oats, rye, and barley, all sourced in New York, and the distillery’s bourbon has earned a score of 95 in The Whisky Bible.

Gin, Vodka, and the James Fenimore Cooper Connection

The clear spirits draw on local literature. Glimmerglass Vodka is made from 100% New York State wheat and takes its name from Glimmerglass, the name Cooper gave Otsego Lake in his novels. Fenimore Gin starts with juniper and citrus peel, then adds eucalyptus, chamomile, star anise, and native New York lilac. It won a 2020 Gold John Barleycorn Award. If gin is your drink, order it in a cocktail at the Beverage Exchange to see how the bartenders use it.

Two Locations in the Village

The Distillery on Railroad Avenue

11 Railroad Avenue is where the spirits are made. During tour season, visitors get a behind-the-scenes look at production, a barrel tasting, a sampling flight in the tasting room, a 20% discount on purchases, and a shot glass to take home. The 2026 tour season has ended, and the distillery plans to post new tour dates for spring 2027.

The Beverage Exchange on Main Street

For a winter visit, head to the Cooperstown Distillery Beverage Exchange at 73 Main Street, on the corner of Main and Pioneer Streets in the center of the village. During the day it works as a tasting counter and shop, selling the distillery’s spirits alongside New York State beers, wines, and ciders, plus bitters, glassware, apparel, and cocktail supplies. Staff can walk you through the lineup and explain how to mix the spirits at home.

A wood and stone bar with shelves of spirits under Edison bulb lights and a Cooperstown Distillery sign

In the evening, the Exchange becomes a cocktail lounge with a gastropub menu built on locally sourced food when available, with daily specials on the chalkboard. After a cold walk down Main Street, it’s a comfortable place to warm up with a drink and an early dinner.

Planning Your Visit in 2026

These are the hours posted on the distillery’s website as of this writing:

  • Beverage Exchange shop and tastings (73 Main St.): Sunday–Thursday 11am–9pm; Friday–Saturday 11am–10pm
  • Beverage Exchange bar and cocktail lounge: Sunday–Thursday 3pm–9pm; Friday–Saturday 3pm–10pm
  • Distillery (11 Railroad Ave.): Monday–Friday 11am–5pm; closed Saturday and Sunday
  • Tours: paused until spring 2027

Hours change with the seasons, so check the distillery’s visit page before you go.

A few tips for the day:

  • All Cooperstown Distillery facilities are ADA compliant.
  • The shop is a good stop for holiday gifts, from bottles and decanters to glassware and bitters.
  • If your travels take you through the Capital Region, the distillery runs a second Beverage Exchange at 453 Broadway in Saratoga Springs.
  • Please drink responsibly, and never drink and drive. Choose a designated driver or arrange a ride back to the cabin before your first tasting.

Make a Day of It in Cooperstown

Because the Beverage Exchange sits on Main Street, it fits easily into a walk through the village. If you want a full craft-beverage day, Brewery Ommegang and Northway Brewing Hop House are close by. Fly Creek Cider Mill is open daily through December 20, 2026, according to its current schedule (KOA), so an early-winter trip can still include fresh cider and baked treats. On Saturday, the year-round Cooperstown Farmers’ Market is a good place to pick up cheese, bread, and other local food to go with whatever bottle you bring home.

Bring a Bottle Back to the Cabin

Pick up a bottle of New York bourbon at the shop, head back to the cabin, and pour a glass by the fire once you’re settled in for the night. If you’re planning a winter weekend near Cooperstown, browse the cabins at Catskills Cabin Rentals and choose your home base.